The safety challenge of lithium-ion batteries for submarines

03/12/2019

For a conventional attack submarine, the performance of its battery is crucial to its survival and operational capacity. A leading supplier in advanced battery has developed a new type of lithium-ion battery system for submarine together with a shipbuilder. This technology is much more efficient than the usual lead acid solution. ALTEN engineers bring their expertise in battery V&V to ensure the safe operation of this new technology in a hostile environment.

Unlike a nuclear submarine that can remain underwater indefinitely (limited only by the amount of food on board), a conventional submarine must regularly return to the surface to recharge its battery, using its diesel engine. This is a risky operation for the submersible, because as it approaches the surface, it becomes easier to detect.

To recharge the battery, the submarine must hoist the air tube (schnorchel) to power its diesel engine

To give an idea, the most efficient U-boat of the Second World War, type XXI, could only sail for one hour diving at a speed of 16 knots (29.6 km/h), and less than ten hours at a speed of 10 knots. (source)

While naval engineers have since made considerable progress in optimizing the naval hydrodynamics of submarines, making them faster and longer endurance underwater; the space available in a submersible remains extremely limited to increase the size of the on-board batteries.
The low diving autonomy is still the Achilles heel of modern submarines, since they use the same lead acid battery technology as their ancestors in 1945.

Architecture of a modern submarine (Kilo 636 class – Russia)

 

Lithium-ion: an innovation for submarines

Introduced by Sony in 1991, lithium-ion battery technology has revolutionized the autonomy of all mobile equipment through its high specific energy (Wh/Kg) and number of duty cycles. Lithium, the smallest and lightest of all metals, has excellent electrochemical properties in relation to its weight.

Comparison of performance between different battery technologies (source)

For the same given weight, lithium-ion batteries can store more energy (longer endurance), provide a higher output current (more powerful). Despite its increasing democratization in our daily lives (e. g. smartphones, portable tools, electric cars, etc.), the application of this technology in the naval sector is very limited.

To date, only one submarine equipped with lithium-ion batteries (SS-511, Japan’s Soryu class) has been launched in October 2018, for commissioning in 2020. This new technology has doubled the diving range, eliminated the danger of producing explosive gas (hydrogen), and reduced the recharge time by increasing the recharge power (source). It offers an interesting alternative to the AIP system (Independent Air Propulsion). The AIP system extends the submarine’s electrical autonomy, allowing it to stay several days in the water, but it carries an additional engine (Stirling or fuel cell) and gas tanks (oxygen and/or hydrogen).

Soryu class submarine. The integration of lithium-ion batteries made it relatively competitive in the Australian contract’s call for tenders (source).

 

Lithium-ion: security risks

Despite the undeniable advantages of lithium-ion batteries, manufacturers are aware of the safety risks of this new technology.
In the first year of service for the Boeing 787 Dreamliner, at least four aircraft suffered from electrical system problems stemming from its lithium-ion batteries.

Boeing 787 lithium-ion battery after the incident

More sensitive to vibrations and temperature variations, a lithium-ion battery can quickly trigger overheating and the phenomenon spreads to neighbouring batteries, causing a “thermal runaway”. (source).

“When the temperature exceeds 100°C, it triggers a cascade of chemical reactions that release heat themselves. If the process is not interrupted, a large amount of energy is suddenly released, about as much as if the electrolyte was burning.”
(Claude Chanson, Managing Director of Recharge, the European association of manufacturers of rechargeable batteries)

However, the submarine meets many of these unfavourable conditions for lithium-ion batteries. Vibrations can be caused by:

  • Tactical manoeuvres of the submarine (e.g. crash dive, “Crazy Ivan”…)
  • Underwater explosions that the submarine may suffer in an attack
  • Torpedo/missile launch from the submarine
  • A possible collision of the submarine with another ship or submarine

A collision must therefore not be allowed to cause a fire of the batteries on board. In 1968, an American submarine (SSN-589, USS Scorpion) was reportedly sunk by the explosion of its own torpedo, following a design defect in the battery. Indeed, vibrations would have triggered a thermal runaway of the torpedo battery, which in turn causes an explosion inside the submersible (source).

 

ALTEN: V&V of the submarine battery system

Faced with this challenge, it is necessary to ensure that the new lithium-ion battery system meets the shipbuilder’s requirements, in order to replace lead-acid battery systems in conventional submarines. A team of ALTEN engineers (composed of project manager, system engineers, V&V engineers and quality engineers) supports a manufacturer of advanced battery systems for industry to:

  • Integrate and analyze end customer requirements
  • Testing and validation (performance and safety)
  • Ensure compliance with quality requirements by suppliers

The battery system of a submarine is generally composed of several tens of batteries (string). Each battery (string) is composed of several modules, a management system (BMS, battery management system) and a contact breaker. Each module itself consists of several accumulators and a liquid cooling system.

A lithium-ion battery module for submarines (Credit @NavyRecognition)

To verify and validate the requirements, ALTEN engineers define the test procedures for lithium-ion batteries on electrical test benches. The purpose of these tests is to measure the battery’s behaviour under real conditions, by simulating charge/discharge currents in different mission profiles. It allows to:

  • Validate performance characteristics:
    the battery capacity (in Ah), the discharge curve and the state of charge (SoC) of the battery, the expected voltage when the battery is charged or discharged…
  • Ensure security in different configurations:
    overload, excessive discharge, overheating….

With battery engineers from various sectors (automotive, aeronautics, energy, etc.), ALTEN brings undeniable expertise in the V&V activities of battery systems to complete the project.

Share